Not
Racist but....Sexist?
In Brent Staple's piece "Black Men and Public
Space", he explains the hardships of being labeled as dangerous by
strangers simply because of his race. Staples comes to terms with the stereotypes
automatically attached to him and learns to live with them. The general
attitude of the piece is positive. Even though Staples is expressing his
frustration with the way people judge him because of his race, he doesn't have
a 'woe-is-me' attitude. The main focus point in this piece is Staples race, but
I picked up on an underlying theme: gender. In all examples and anecdotes
Staples uses, he is either intimidating a woman or he is not gender specific.
In his first paragraph, he writes about a woman who started running when she
saw him coming down the street. He also writes about going into a jewelry shop,
where the female proprietor brought out a guard dog to get him to leave. In
paragraph five, he writes "After dark...I often see women who fear the
worst from me", and then states that women are very vulnerable to
violence. However, he makes no mention of men. The he implies that men are
effected by his presence is when he writes about people, "black, white,
male, or female" (paragraph 2), who lock their car doors when he crosses
the street in front of them. All his examples make women look weak. Not only
that, but because he uses the examples to prove that people are judging him
incorrectly, he makes women look foolish for being scared of him. His point was
that he affects the atmosphere around him in negative ways, but I think he
should have represented both sexes more equally. We no longer live in a world
where women are defenseless. Many women can fend for themselves, some even
better than other men! Staple's portrayal of women is sexist and slightly
offensive.
I like how you pointed out the racial injustice, but also the gender prejudice. (And your pink theme supports your claim.nice)
ReplyDeleteI like how you went through the piece to find evidence!
ReplyDeleteThe gender issue was brought up briefly in class, but I didn't really think too much about it!